THG
  • Аудио и видео
  • Бизнес и рынок
  • Видеокарты
  • Домашний компьютер
  • Игры и индустрия
  • Конкурсы
  • Накопители
  • Образование
  • Периферия
  • Платформы
  • Проекторы и мониторы
  • Процессоры
  • Сети и WiFi
  • Смартфоны и ноутбуки
  • Собери сам
  • Софт и утилиты
  • Фото
  • Обзоры
    • Смартфоны и ноутбуки
    • Аудио и видео
    • Проекторы и мониторы
    • Процессоры
    • Бизнес и рынок
    • Видеокарты
    • Домашний компьютер
    • Игры и индустрия
    • Конкурсы
    • Накопители
    • Периферия
    • Платформы
    • Техника для дома и сада
    • Сети и WiFi
    • Собери сам
    • Софт и утилиты
    • Фото
  • Статьи
  • Подборки
  • Новости
  • Форум
  • Контакты
  • Главная
THG
THG
  • Обзоры
    • Смартфоны и ноутбуки
    • Аудио и видео
    • Проекторы и мониторы
    • Процессоры
    • Бизнес и рынок
    • Видеокарты
    • Домашний компьютер
    • Игры и индустрия
    • Конкурсы
    • Накопители
    • Периферия
    • Платформы
    • Техника для дома и сада
    • Сети и WiFi
    • Собери сам
    • Софт и утилиты
    • Фото
  • Статьи
  • Подборки
  • Новости
  • Форум
  • Контакты
  • Главная
  • Видеокарты

GeForce3 Under Attack: ATi’s Radeon 8500 Previewed

  • 14.08.2001
8bb07a00ad43e7ff69fc70d7fb24759f
8bb07a00ad43e7ff69fc70d7fb24759f




<!—#set var="article_header" value="GeForce3 Under Attack:
ATi’s Radeon 8500 Previewed» —>


Introduction

Intro

Today ATi announces the long awaited R200, from now on called ‘Radeon 8500’. ‘Announcing’ doesn’t mean you will be able to buy it anytime soon (although ‘soon’ is obviously a rather subjective measure), but a few meant-to-be lucky people of the so-called ‘online press’ were blessed with R200-samples last week to spill the beans about the upcoming ATi 3D-chip.

Lately the times have been quite rough for the Canadian 3D-chip and card maker, which used to be on the top of the food chain only a couple of years ago. Saying the magic word ‘3D-acceleration’ today goes along naturally with the brand NVIDIA, and since this Sunnyvale, CA based company finally completed their task of saturating each and every segment in the PC 3D business, ATi’s star has been falling quite rapidly.

ATi’s last year’s release of the Radeon-family had ensured a lot of press and attention for the guys in red and white, but in the end it turned out that Radeon had only been a half-hearted attempt to push NVIDIA from its throne, because the pure hardware features of Radeon were unable to compete with the beefy products of the Californian 3D-Monster company. This time ATi decided to play all its cards. Radeon 8500 is supposed to kick NVIDIA’s top products were it hurts. Thus Radeon 8500 comes with tons of features as well as an overdose of fill rate and memory bandwidth power. It seems as if ATi decided that this time it’s got to be all or nothing. Let’s see if the new R200 has the guts and steroids to do the job.

Features, Features, Features …

Block Diagram

Normal people with sensible interests and serious problems would be petrified by the pure feature-list of ATi’s upcoming 3D chip. It’s so much stuff that I didn’t even contemplate explaining it all here in this article. Luckily ATi has released a lot of technology info about Radeon 8500 in the last weeks and months already, so that those of you, who really need to know all about those features with their funky names, can find a wealth of information all over the web, including right here. All the ones of you blessed with a minimal amount of common sense should be satisfied with this short summary of Radeon 8500’s features: ‘It’s a beefed up GeForce3 and then some’. OK?

I know, the majority of you is of course not satisfied with that, which does not mean that I am daring to draw any conclusions about your common sense. To keep everyone happy I will quickly summarize the most important issues of each feature, to give you a pretty good idea what it actually really is.

‘Truform’ — Canadian For ‘N-Patches’

ATi’s ‘Truform’ stand for a special, and actually rather sensible as well as exciting way of implementing ‘higher order surfaces‘ into 3D-games, regardless if new or old. It is capable of making a ‘curved surface’ out of a ‘flat triangle’. Now we, the informed minority of this planet, always knew that triangles happen to be flat, even flatter than pancakes. For the others, who thought that triangles weren’t flat before, ATi introduced their version of DX8’s N-patches, which uses the normals (surface vectors) of each vertex that describes a triangle to calculate a curved surface that of course consists of more triangles. This procedure is also called ‘tesselation’ and ‘Truform’ allows the adjustment of how many new (and of course smaller) triangles will be generated out of the original ‘flat’ triangle. ATi (and fellow journalists) claim that this procedure does not cost any performance, but it is logical that this is not quite the whole truth. Once a triangle has been replaced by a lot of smaller triangles, the rendering pipeline has to handle the smaller triangles, which does of course cost performance. The catch of «Truform» however is that it has the ability to make 3D-objects look much more realistic while carrying the risk of creating artifacts (not every flat surface wants to be curved). It can be used in any 3D-game, regardless if old or new and thus it seems to be a smarter approach than NVIDIA’s spline-stuff, but we’ll have to see what developers think about it. One thing is for sure; I doubt that ‘Truform’ will indeed come for free in terms of performance.

‘SmartShader’ — Another Programmable Vertex and Pixel Processor

Block Diagram

While NVIDIA in unison with Microsoft called GeForce3’s programmable vertex processor ‘Vertex Shader‘ and the programmable pixel processor ‘Pixel Shader‘, ATi came up with the name ‘SmartShader’ for both. The programmable vertex processor of Radeon 8500 comes with the same functionality as GeForce3’s. The reason why ATi considers Radeon 8500’s pixel shader ‘smarter’ than NVIDIA’s, is the fact that ATi listened to the complaints of developers, who considered GeForce3’s pixel shader as not sophisticated enough, especially in comparison to the rather sophisticated vertex shader of GeForce3. ‘Smartshader’ is able to use up to six texel-inputs per pixel shader program, adds a new instruction set and allows longer programs (22 instead of 12 instructions per program). The specifications of Smartshader’s different programmable pixel processor are implemented into DirectX 8.1 and while GeForce3 will remain unable to allow six texel-inputs per pass, it should communicate with the other instruction set once it runs under DirectX 8.1. All in all, ‘Smartshader’ is a good thing and will certainly be welcomed by developers.

SmartShader allows stuff like:

  • Procedural deformation
  • Geometry compression
  • Morphing
  • Fur rendering
  • Skeletal animation
  • Keyframe interpolation
  • Full bump mapping support: environment mapped (Blinn), emboss, dot3
  • Anisotropic lighting
  • Phong shading
  • Light and gloss maps
  • Reflections, shadows, spotlights, texture morphing
  • Texture coordinate transformation
  • Texture coordinate generation for spherical, dual paraboloid and cubic environment mapping
  • Projected textures
  • Video textures

‘SmoothVision’ — Sophisticated Multi Sampling FSAA

The first time we heard of multi sampling full scene anti aliasing goes back to good old 3dfx and Voodoo 5, but the first chip with a sophisticated multi sampling FSAA was NVIDIA’s GeForce3. Now ATi christened their more advanced MSFSAA-solution ‘SmoothVision’. The trick of ‘Smoothvision’ is its programmability. The developer chooses the pattern that will be used for the multi-sampling.

SmoothVision

Again, ATi improved a technology used in GeForce3. It is too bad that none of the Radeon 8500 press samples were able to run with ‘SmoothVision’ enabled, because then I might have been able to tell you a bit more about it or even show you some sample pictures. Basically, SmoothVision allows more flexibility than GeForce3’s Quincunx, but it also requires some more work of the game developer. Radeon 8500 allows up to 16 different programmable sample modes and up to 16 samples per pixel for its FSAA. While 16 samples per pixel would obviously prove very costly in terms of rendering performance, Radeon 8500 gives developers the flexibility to choose the most attractive as well as most effective FSAA-method for their game.

Let me not forget that the multi-sampling support of Radeon 8500 also allows so extremely important stuff as depth-of-field or motion blur.

High Performance Memory And HyperZ II

We were very impressed with GeForce3’s crossbar memory controller, which has the ability to use the available memory bandwidth much more effectively, as we will see in particular with NVIDIA’s brand new Detonator 4 driver set. Radeon 8500 does not come with a solution quite as sophisticated, but its memory controller is also dividing the 128-bit memory interface. While GeForce3’s crossbar controller splits the 128 data lines in 4 blocks with 32-bits each, Radeon’s memory controller is using a two-channel design with two blocks of 64 bit to make data transfers more efficient. The memory controller is able to run with SGRAM as well as (DDR-) SDRAM, it can be equipped with 16 — 256 MB of memory and can run at a memory clock of up to 300 MHZ (600 MHz DDR). Our test sample was running its memory at 275 MHz (550 MHz DDR).

To save memory bandwidth as well, ATi improved Radeon’s ‘hidden surface removal’ technique, summarized under the term «HyperZ». Radeon 8500 comes with an improved ‘HyperZ II’. The idea behind it is still the same as with the original HyperZ (Fast Z-Clear, Z-Compression, Hierarchical-Z), but ATi improved (or rather fixed) the algorithms used by HyperZ. The result is rather impressive, as we will see in the VillageMark-scores of Radeon 8500.

HydraVision — One High End Card With Two Displays

First there was Matrox and its ‘DualHead’, then came NVIDIA with ‘Twinview’ and finally ATi launched its own two-display-solution called ‘HydraVision’. While Matrox is equipping all of its cards with this practical feature, NVIDIA has so far only equipped its ‘value’ GeForce2MX-line of cards with a second display outputs (of questionable quality). Radeon 8500 will be the first high end 3D-card with two monitor outputs. It allows every kind of mixture between CRT, digital flat panel and TV, as long as they are only two. Each of the two displays can be driven with its own resolution and refresh rate. Once again I’d like to express my disappointment about the fact that the current test samples do not support this feature as well yet.

‘Charisma Engine II’ — The T&L Unit Of Radeon 8500

The name ‘Charisma Engine II’ found in Radeon 8500 stands for the ‘fixed function’ T&L-engine. The majority of games is still using this path since there isn’t a whole lot of software titles available yet that would support vertex and pixel shader programs. Radeon 8500’s T&L-engine is very powerful (over 60 Mtriangles/s) and able to process a lot more triangles than the T&L-unit of GeForce3, as you will see in the benchmarks.

‘Pixel Tapestry II’ -The Pixel Rendering Unit

‘Pixel Tapestry II’, the pixel-rendering unit, consists of four pipelines and it looks (ATi’s information is rather inconclusive) as if 3 texels can be applied per pixel per clock, while twice the amount of texels (6) can be applied per pass (which can take quite a lot longer than one clock cycle). With Radeon 8500’s core clock of 250 MHz this would lead to a pixel fill rate of 1 GPixels/s and a texel fill rate of 3 GTexels/s. For some strange reason, two different ATi white papers are claiming two different texel fill rates of 2 GTexels/s or 2.4 GTexels/s respectively. Our benchmarks lead to believe that the actual texel fill rate should be around 2 GTexels/s, making it look as if Radeon 8500 is only able to apply two texels per pixel per clock cycle.

‘Video Immersion II’ — ATi’s Strength In Video

There is not much to say to ‘Video Immersion II’. So far ATi has been able to show the competition how digital video playback should look and Radeon 8500 is going to follow this tradition. The new chip will come with hardware accelerated MPEG2-decoding, motion compensation and iDCT for top-notch DVD-playback as well as MPEG2-recording. ‘Video Immersion II’ comes with an improved de-interlacing algorithm and new frame rate conversion techniques to improve sharpness and avoid jittering. Radeon 8500 will also support high quality HDTV. ATi’s test samples were unfortunately also unable to do any video playback, so we were unable to test this feature as well.

And The Rest

Let me quickly list the remaining details of Radeon 8500:

  • .15 micron process, 60 million transistors
  • AGP 4x and 2x support
  • Optimized for Pentium 4’s SSE2 as well as Athlon’s 3Dnow!
  • 400 MHz DAC
  • 165 MHz TDMS transmitter
  • Default core clock 250 MHz
  • Default Memory Clock 275 MHz, 8,800 MB/s bandwidth
  • Default Amount of Memory 64 MB
  • 128-bit 2D-engine
  • 8-bit stencil buffer
  • Priority buffers
  • Motion blur and depth of field
  • Point sampled, bilinear, trilinear and 16:1 anisotropic filtering
  • 3D texturing, volume texture compression
  • DirectX 8.1 and OpenGL 1.3 support
  • integrated TV-out, RAMDAC, TMDS-transmitter

Unfortunately ATi would not supply us with data about the power consumption of the chip or its die size. However, it seems as if the chip is very fully packed, since ATi was not able to find space enough for a second RAMDAC as required by HydraVision.

The Sample

ATi Radeon 8500

Current test samples of Radeon 8500 are using chip with the stepping ‘A12’. This stepping has still got several known issues, as already mentioned above. It was neither able to run FSAA, nor video playback or HydraVision. ATi is currently waiting for stepping ‘A13’, which is supposed the final stepping for the cards that will go on sale in September.

Memory Chip

Our card was equipped with Hyundai 3.6 ns DDR-SDRAM, which is required for memory clocks of 275 MHz.

Here is the Powerstrip screen to show the clock settings:

Powerstrip

Driver Screen Shots

There is not too much to say about the driver. Here are the shots:

Driver Screen Shots

The display tab allows you to choose your two display devices.

Driver Screen Shots

This one is certainly known from other ATi cards, the color tab.

Driver Screen Shots

The OpenGL tab allows the usual stuff. VSYNC is disabled by default and you can choose between no, 2-sample or 4-sample anti-aliasing for OpenGL-games. Our board would not function properly once FSAA was enabled under OpenGL.

Driver Screen Shots

Under Direct3D VSYNC is actually enabled by default and you can see the ‘SmoothVision’-slider for ATi’s FSAA-solution. Unfortunately this feature is not working properly with A12-samples.

Driver Screen Shots

This tab doesn’t do much, but I added it for completeness.

Radeon 7500 — Also Released Today

ATi is not only launching its new high-end product Radeon 8500 today, but also a card with the name ‘Radeon 7500’.

Radeon 7500 is basically a ‘tuned’ version of the good old Radeon. The die-shrink to 0.15 micron process technology enabled ATi to run this ‘old design’ at higher clock speeds. ATi added the HydraVision back-end of the RadeonVE and supposedly also the memory interface of Radeon 8500 (not confirmed).

Block Diagram

You can see the ‘Charisma Engine’ T&L unit and the two pixel rendering pipelines. Radeon 7500 comes with two integrated RAMDACs, so that it doesn’t require an external chip to support two CRTs. The memory interface is able to support memory clocks up to 250 MHz. Our test sample was running at 250 MHz core clock and 230 MHz memory clock.

Radeon 7500 is targeted at NVIDIA’s future ‘GeForce3MX’ chip, aka ‘NV17’. Right now Radeon 7500 is well able to compete with GeForce2 GTS and GeForce2 Pro cards. Depending on its price it could be a very interesting mid-range solution that easily beats NVIDIA’s GeForce2 MX line.

Detonator 4 — NVIDIA Spoils It All

You have to admit that ATi is making a gutsy move to release Radeon 8500 today, considering that the final spin of silicon isn’t ready and several features of the test samples are not functioning right now. ATi was obviously of the opinion that the brute force of Radeon’s superior theoretical fill rate and memory bandwidth would be good enough to beat NVIDIA’s GeForce3 badly enough to make possible buyers forget about the missing SmoothVision, video and HydraVision functionality.

NVIDIA, however, has been fully aware of the upcoming R200 launch and the strategists in Sunnyvale decided to drop some kind of bomb close to the release date of Radeon 8500. The new driver set that goes by the name of ‘Detonator 4’ will be released this week, but the press has already been equipped with it. The new driver with the revision number 2080 is able to boost GeForce3’s performance in a very significant way, making it extremely hard for Radeon 8500 to beat its competitor from NVIDIA.

We had a closer look at ‘Detonator 4’, which has already been hyped quite a lot. We can already now tell you that we don’t agree with a ‘Thank you, NVIDIA’. We think that Detonator 4 has been ready for weeks now and that consumers had to wait for its release only to ensure that NVIDIA could spoil ATi’s Radeon 8500 launch. I personally don’t consider this as an example of admirable sportsmanship, but who except me in this business would possibly care about such old-fashioned or even honorable things?

NVIDIA’s new 2080-driver has one important improvement over previous driver revisions. The software engineers under Dwight Diercks were able to squeeze an impressive amount of useable memory bandwidth out of GeForce3’s admittedly excellent crossbar memory controller design. However, not all applications are benefiting from the new driver, as you can see in the chart below:

Detonator 4

The extremely useful synthetic fill rate test that is built into 3D Mark 2001 could show a fill rate improvement of up to 29%, mainly found in high resolutions and 32-bit color. In actual fact, the fill rate at 1600x1200x32 is now as high as at 1024x768x16, which is not only remarkable, but almost suspiciously high.

Quake 3 Arena can nowadays be considered as a game with rather low expectations to hardware, which is why the fill rate increase generated by the new driver is directly translating in up to 29% higher game frame rates (when it is fill rate limited!) at 1600x1200x32. You can see that Radeon 8500 has to beat a much stronger enemy here.

AquaMark (AquaNox) and 3DMark are still benefiting quite nicely from driver 2080 as well, but the picture changes already with Dronez, which in worst-case scenario is actually performing up to 1% slower than with the old driver revision 1241.

It goes downhill from here. Evolva may lose a bit or may gain abit, depending on the resolution. PowerVR’s VillageMark doesn’t give a rat’s butt about the driver revision whatsoever, but Giants is the real loser. 29% SLOWER is pretty much unacceptable.

All in all NVIDIA’s Detonator 4 release leaves a bad taste in my mouth. It was obviously timed for a release date that would possibly hurt ATi. Fine, if this makes the guys feel better. I’d prefer a driver release date that gives the customers the best driver as soon as possible and as late as necessary to ensure reliable operation. What I don’t like is that the new driver shows its biggest improvements in the typical benchmarking programs, such as 3DMark2001, Quake3 or AquaMark. Rarely used game benchmarks see only little or no gain, while Giants is even losing out considerably. I leave it up to you to make a rhyme on that. Detonator 4 is a good thing for most owners of NVIDIA based cards, but I challenge the choice of its release date as well as the fact that at least one (new!) game does better with the old driver.

Benchmark Considerations

Theoretic Data

If you look at the pure fill rate and memory bandwidth data, Radeon 8500 should easily beat GeForce3. That’s what we expect and that’s what ATi expects too. We will have to see if Radeon 8500 will be able to live up to those expectations, or if NVIDIA’s Detonator 4 release was is able to spoil the show.

If you should (like me) have thought that all the fancy game demos and benchmarks made for the GeForce3-launch would run with full feature settings on Radeon 8500 as well, then you are sadly mistaken. Even though Radeon 8500 should indeed run with vertex programs, pixel shader stuff and bump mapping enabled, neither Dronez, nor Vulpine’s GLMark would actually allow that. Obviously both games were not programmed for DirectX 8, but for GeForce3 only. AquaNox as well as 3DMark2001 are well able to recognize the DirectX8-features of Radeon 8500. It’s a shame that Dronez and GLMark were obviously not programmed properly to check for the features of a 3D-card. Both games are only looking for GeForce3.

Radeon 7500 has a high memory bandwidth and a good texel fill rate, but its pixel fill rate is far worse than GeForce2 Pro’s. Let’s see how the new ATi midrange card sticks up against its competitor from NVIDIA.

Benchmark Setup

Hardware Setup
Motherboard Asus P4T, Intel 850, BIOS 1005 beta 3
Memory 2 x 128 MB Infineon PC800 RDRAM
Processor Intel Pentium 4 1.7 GHz
Network Card 3Com 3C905B-TX
Hard Drive IBM DTLA-307030, ATA100, 7200 RPM, FAT32
Graphics Cards
ATi Radeon 8500 64 MB 3.6 ns DDR-SDRAM
250 MHz Core Clock
275 MHz Memory Clock
Driver 7167
ATi Radeon 7500 64 MB 4 ns DDR-SDRAM
270 MHz Core Clock
230 MHz Memory Clock
Driver 7167
NVIDIA GeForce3 Reference Card 64 MB 4 ns DDR-SDRAM
200 MHz Core Clock
230 MHz Memory Clock
Driver 2080
NVIDIA GeForce2 Pro Reference Card 64 MB 4.5 ns DDR-SDRAM
200 MHz Core Clock
200 MHz Memory Clock
Driver 2080
Software Setup
Operating System Windows Me 4.90.3000
DirectX 8.1 beta 648
Quake 3 Arena Retail Version
Evolva Demo Build 944
DronezMark Downloadable Version
Giants Retail Version, Patched to rev. 1396
AquaMark AquaNox Downloadable Demo
3DMark2001 Downloadable www.madonion.com
Refresh Rates 85 Hz for each screen resolution

Benchmark Results

3D Mark 2001

For this special occasion I decided to start with the results of 3DMark2001, because those numbers are pretty explanatory for the behavior of the cards in the game benchmarks further down.

3D Mark Overall

At 1024x768x32 Radeon 8500 is just about able to beat GeForce3, while the NVIDIA-card has a slight edge over Radeon 8500 at 1600x1200x32. This looked a lot different with the old NVIDIA drivers. GeForce3 with driver rev. 1241 is some 800 points behind the new ATi flagship, but that’s yesterdays news.

Radeon 7500 is easily outperforming GeForce2 Pro in 3DMark2001, which I consider rather remarkable.

3D Mark Pixel Fill Rate

This sub-benchmark of 3DMark2001 is symptomatic for the results you will see in the games. At 16-bit color Radeon 8500 is reasonably close to its theoretical fill rate maximum of 1000 Mpixles/s and untouchable for GeForce3. However, while GeForce3 remains rock-steady with its pixel fill rate even at 32-bit color thanks to Detonator 4, Radeon 8500 is dropping, although it has the higher memory bandwidth. At 1600x1200x32 GeForce3 has an even higher fill rate than Radeon 8500, although the ATi chip has a higher core clock as well as about 10% more memory bandwidth. ATi will have to do something about this situation. The drivers are still early and there should be a lot of room for improvement, but it cannot be that the NVIDIA card beats Radeon 8500 in this discipline.

Things are a lot more pleasant for Radeon 7500. It is much closer to its theoretical fill rate maximum that GeForce2 Pro. GeForce2 Pro may beat the new ATi chip, but not very impressively. The results wouldn’t let you guess that the theoretical fill rate maximum of GeForce2 Pro is some hefty 50% higher than that of Radeon 7500.

3D Mark 2001, Continued

3D Mark Texel Fill Rate

In terms of texel fill rate (important for multi-texturing) GeForce3 is utterly unable to beat Radeon 8500. The same is valid for Radeon 7500 and GeForce2 Pro. The new ATi cards can apply more texels per cycle per pipeline than their NVIDIA-counterparts.

3D Mark 2001 T&L Performance

This chart shows another strength of Radeon 8500. Its triangle rate is much higher than GeForce3’s. The T&L-unit of Radeon 8500 beats GeForce3 to the punch. Only Radeon 7500 doesn’t look too good here.

3D Mark 2001, Continued

3D Mark 2001 Special features

For the time being, GeForce3 is able to beat the young Radeon 8500 in pixel shader stuff and the bump mapping (which is pixel shader stuff as well). However, it seems as if GeForce3’s vertex shader performs rather badly. Radeon 8500 scores almost twice as high in this test.

Summary 3D Mark 2001

In this comparison 3D Mark 2001 has proven to be an invaluable tool to evaluate the performance of modern 3D-chips, making further gaming benchmarks almost obsolete.

Radeon 8500 is clearly suffering from an ineffectively used high-bandwidth memory interface. This can hopefully be sorted out with a better driver. We should not forget that it took NVIDIA almost 6 months until they had a driver that can use GeForce3’s crossbar memory controller as effectively as Detonator 4. Still, there is no excuse why Radeon should perform worse than GeForce3, bearing in mind that it has the higher core clock and memory bandwidth.

NVIDIA, the proud provider of the very first ‘GPU’ with integrated ‘T&L’ should be a little bit ashamed for the bad figure that GeForce3 makes in the T&L-performance chart. ATi has clearly overtaken NVIDIA on that one. Nobody knows if the T&L-performance really matters, but NVIDIA was the one that told us how important T&L is. It should go without saying that we expect the fastest T&L units from NVIDIA, not from ATi.

Quake 3 Arena

Quake 3 Arena Demo1

The Quake 3 performance chart looks almost just as the fill rate chart of 3D Mark 2001. At 16-bit color GeForce3 is unable to touch Radeon 8500, but at 32-it color Radeon 8500 falls back behind GeForce3. Radeon 7500 is unable to compete against GeForce2 Pro up until high resolution at 32-bit color.

Quake 3 Arena NV15

This chart is rather inconclusive and doesn’t really tell us a whole lot. This benchmark is basically CPU-bound and the differences are only able to show how well the driver is P4-optimized. It seems as if NVIDIA has a slight edge.

AquaNox- AquaMark

Aquamark

GeForce3 is easily beating Radeon 8500 in this one, which is a bit of surprising. This could either be a driver issue or a pixel shader issue. This game is hardly fill rate limited. Radeon 7500 is competing quite nicely with GeForce2 Pro.

Dronez — DronezMark

All the fancy vertex and pixel shader features as well as bump mapping had to be disabled for this benchmark run, because the game wouldn’t enable those features on Radeon 8500. This is not a mistake of the ATi board, but of the game.

Dronez

GeForce3 is able to win this one as well, although the edge over Radeon 8500 isn’t big. Radeon 7500 is once more doing quite well against GeForce2 Pro.

Evolva

Evolva is a DirectX 7 game that makes heavy use of dot3 bump mapping. It is still a rather tough benchmark.

Evolva

This is the first game that didn’t really benefit from NVIDIA’s Detonator 4 driver. Without the help of this driver GeForce3 is pretty much lost. Radeon 8500 wins all the way, although not with much of a distance.

VillageMark

This benchmark comes from PowerVR and is meant to show the benefits of the tile render architecture over the classic method used by most other chips. There is a huge overlap in the benchmarks scene (high depth complexity) and the objects are intentionally sorted back to front. Normally only Kyro cards can really score well here. Let’s see how well the HyperZ II of Radeon 8500 is doing.

VillageMark

Radeon 8500 destroys GeForce3 in this benchmark! I have to be fair and admit that the triple-texturing in this benchmark doesn’t really help the NVIDIA cards with their even number of rendering units as well. Still, the defeat is clear. This time it seems pretty obvious that ATi’s hidden surface removal actually works. NVIDIA’s ‘z-occlusion culling’ doesn’t stand a chance, because it simply doesn’t work with scenes that are sorted back-to-front.

Giants

Giants

GeForce3’s behavior in this benchmark is rather strange, as it scores higher frame rates in 32-bit color than in 16-bit color. Still, it is able to beat Radeon 8500, even though it scored much better with the old 12.41 driver.

Prices

Radeon 8500 — $ 399, available end of September

Radeon 7500 — $ 179, available mid of September

Summary

It seems obvious that if NVIDIA’s intention was to screw up ATi’s Radeon 8500-launch then the decision makers in Sunnyvale should be proud. NVIDIA will think «to hell with sportsmanship. We won and that’s all that counts!» Well, I cannot say that I am a big admirer of this philosophy, but I know that I am of a dying breed.

Still, Radeon 8500 has huge potential and after almost losing the first round, it might well come back and win the next few rounds. Radeon 8500 has the biggest muscles in this contest and now all it takes is to train the cerebellum. There is no doubt that the hardware engineers of the Canadian chip and board maker have done an excellent job. Radeon 8500 has all that it takes: Brute force in terms of core clock, pipelines and memory bandwidth as well as a huge set of nifty features that sets it apart from any other 3D-chip in the market. Now it’s the time of the software engineers to build up upon the fundament laid by the board architects. Let’s hope that ATi has learned from past mistakes and that its driver department has been improved. It will be tough to compete with Dwight Diercks group of software engineers, who have so far proven to be the best driver makers in the industry.

I like Radeon 8500 and I won’t let NVIDIA spoil my happiness about the fact that a 3D-chip maker has put a product together that can give NVIDIA’s flagship a run for its money. The timed Detonator 4 release reminds me of old Intel tactics and it lets ATi win a lot of sympathy. Times have changed and while NVIDIA is on its way to become GeForcilla, ATi is looking more and more like the AMD we remember from the days before Athlon. Today, a world without ATi would be like a world without AMD. Intel and NVIDIA would do with us whatever they want. We need the competition.

I’d also like to send a few words of criticism across to Toronto. I don’t think that it was a wise decision to launch Radeon 8500 now. The product is obviously not quite ready yet and we testers didn’t appreciate the fact that three important features of the card wouldn’t work. I hope the next Radeon 8500 that ends up in my hands will be 100% operational.

Radeon 7500 seems like an interesting product, especially for the price. However, before I come to any final conclusion I will have to test it against Kyro II and others.







Вам также может понравиться
U4cgMqDxkeRdvWncNHXoM6 970 80 png
Читать
  • Видеокарты

Лучшие видеокарты для игр в 2026 году

  • THG
  • 13.01.2026
luchshaya videokarta 01
Читать
  • Видеокарты
  • Подборки

Лучшая видеокарта для игр: текущий анализ рынка

  • Редакция THG
  • 22.11.2024
ac20619a1ab87a27a2002ae94e699459
Читать
  • Видеокарты

Выбираем подержанную видеокарту

  • 08.09.2020
13eb5823092f9dfdac4d5a55e77bafd4
Читать
  • Видеокарты

Всё, что мы знаем об Nvidia RTX 3080 и Ampere

  • 18.06.2020
7d7286276a25ac06cbf5759f100a10a2
Читать
  • Видеокарты

Иерархия видеокарт AMD и Nvidia: сравнительная таблица

  • 30.05.2019
6059a3d20c04b90170b9b5fade17f520
Читать
  • Видеокарты

Какие видеокарты лучше: референсные или партнёрские?

  • 08.05.2019
5981eb2d43d076d3a26adcd01c7aabf6
Читать
  • Видеокарты

AMD Radeon VII: обзор и тест видеокарты для игр в 4K

  • 15.03.2019
8057c28a42e248ccb252112de8ef06cc
Читать
  • Видеокарты

Nvidia GeForce RTX 2070 Founders Edition: обзор и тест видеокарты

  • THG
  • 29.01.2019

Добавить комментарий Отменить ответ

Ваш адрес email не будет опубликован. Обязательные поля помечены *


Подписывайтесь на наши страницы в социальных сетях
Telegram

Свежие статьи

  • Почему конец партии в дураке решает расчет, а не везение
  • Обзор ноутбука ASUS ROG Zephyrus Duo 2026 (GX651)
  • Тонометр на запястье и титан с керамикой: в России стартовали продажи HUAWEI WATCH D3 и HUAWEI WATCH 6
  • М.Видео начинает предзаказ на HUAWEI MatePad Air: ультратонкий планшет с OLED-экраном PaperMatte
  • Обзор игрового кресла Zone 51 Chevron: крепкий середняк с претензией на звание боевого товарища
Популярные записи
  • Напряжённая карточная партия при свечах 1
    Почему конец партии в дураке решает расчет, а не везение
    • 12.11.2026
  • Без имени 2
    Обзор ноутбука ASUS ROG Zephyrus Duo 2026 (GX651)
    • 14.10.2026
  • WATCH 6 продакт фото2 3
    Тонометр на запястье и титан с керамикой: в России стартовали продажи HUAWEI WATCH D3 и HUAWEI WATCH 6
    • 14.10.2026
  • Wooki 晴光蓝AiryBlue 4
    М.Видео начинает предзаказ на HUAWEI MatePad Air: ультратонкий планшет с OLED-экраном PaperMatte
    • 29.09.2026
  • Photo 2026 09 28 15 47 5
    Обзор игрового кресла Zone 51 Chevron: крепкий середняк с претензией на звание боевого товарища
    • 28.09.2026
Последние записи
  • Contract signing meeting stockcake
    Чем созаёмщик отличается от поручителя
    • 28.09.2026
  • 10USB30
    10 лучших флешек USB 3.0: сравнительный обзор на любой бюджет
    • 05.07.2026
  • 17
    HONOR MagicPad 4: ультратонкий планшет с процессором уровня ПК стартовал в России
    • 04.07.2026
Категории
  • 4G
  • Аудио и видео
  • Без рубрики
  • Бизнес и рынок
  • Видеокарты
  • Домашний компьютер
  • Игры и индустрия
  • Конкурсы
  • Накопители
  • Новости
  • Обзоры
  • Образование
  • Периферия
  • Платформы
  • Подборки
  • Проекторы и мониторы
  • Процессоры
  • Сети и WiFi
  • Смартфоны и ноутбуки
  • Собери сам
  • Софт и утилиты
  • Статьи
  • Техника для дома и сада
  • Фото
Архив
THG
  • Обзоры
  • Статьи
  • Подборки
  • Новости
  • Форум
  • Контакты
  • Главная
IT-новости, обзоры смартфонов, гаджетов и компьютерного железа

Powered by
Necessary cookies enable essential site features like secure log-ins and consent preference adjustments. They do not store personal data.
None
Functional cookies support features like content sharing on social media, collecting feedback, and enabling third-party tools.
None
Analytical cookies track visitor interactions, providing insights on metrics like visitor count, bounce rate, and traffic sources.
None
Advertisement cookies deliver personalized ads based on your previous visits and analyze the effectiveness of ad campaigns.
None
Unclassified cookies are cookies that we are in the process of classifying, together with the providers of individual cookies.
None
Powered by